[Yes, absolutely, tell him literally everything, that is how priests work,]

Hm? Of course not. In my line of work, I meet people who aren't human more often than you think.

[His eye closes - its meant to be a wink, but with his eyepatch, it probably just looks like he's blinking.]

If you want to cause trouble, or hurt or kill others, we'd need to have a different conversation. But for now...I'll turn a blind eye to whatever you are.