I stepped back so that I could watch how this continued to unfold and I have to say that after more has come to light, I'm really disappointed. I was optimistic to hear that people would get a fresh chance, only for them to get increasingly weirder and more reaching revisions the second time around.

As a prospective player, it also really sucked to see you guys knee-jerk close this post because a few socks replied. I thought it was great to have a platform where this could be discussed openly, but you decided to shut it down when it started to get tough.

I am going to echo the voices of those below me saying that out of fairness, your solution should have been to accept the applications that clearly met the standards you have sought to lay out rather than giving everyone blanket revisions.

One of those players declined your revisions because of this. You are actively driving players away, both present and potential. Why are you doubling down on this, when it's clearly unfair?